GreenU's method for calculating CO₂e avoided by collecting and recycling milk cartons

GreenU has published its method for calculating the greenhouse gas emissions (CO₂e) avoided by collecting and recycling paper-based milk cartons, together with a review of the scientific studies it rests on. The method applies to the carton collection programmes GreenU coordinates in Hanoi, Da Nang, Quang Ninh and Ho Chi Minh City, with the recycling plant located in Ho Chi Minh City. This article summarises the science behind the method; the full document is at the end.
The method answers two different questions
Companies usually ask one question: how many tonnes of CO₂e does carton recycling cut? In fact these are two questions with different boundaries, so the method keeps two separate ledgers built from the same collection data.
- Ledger A, corporate inventory: how much the end-of-life emissions of packaging a company has sold (Scope 3, Category 12 under the GHG Protocol) fall when that brand's own cartons move from landfill or incineration to recycling. This reduction is recorded in the inventory.
- Ledger B, programme avoided emissions: compared with a scenario without the programme, how many tonnes of CO₂e the whole collection and recycling chain avoids. This figure is reported separately and is not deducted from the inventory (per ISO 14064-2 and WBCSD guidance, 2023).
Scientific basis
A milk carton is roughly 75% paper fibre, 20% PE plastic and 5% aluminium (Robertson, 2021). In landfill, the fibre decomposes anaerobically and releases methane. When burned, the PE layer releases fossil CO₂. Recycling avoids both sources of emissions while recovering the fibre and the polyethylene–aluminium mix (PolyAl) to replace other materials.
Using IPCC default factors (2006, refined 2019), each tonne of dry cartons sent to landfill generates about 1.2 to 3.0 tonnes of CO₂e of methane over its lifetime, depending on the type of site. This is far larger than the benefit of material substitution. The result therefore depends first and foremost on where the cartons would go without the programme: landfill, incinerator or open burning.
International studies point the same way. Turner et al. (2015) calculated the composite packaging recycling chain in the UK on its own: net emissions of −0.45 tonnes of CO₂e per tonne after crediting material substitution. Zhang et al. (2026) found similar results for a school-based collection model in China. Roland Berger (2022) estimated that each 1-litre carton recycled rather than discarded in Europe avoids about 48 g of CO₂e, equivalent to 1.5 to 1.9 tonnes of CO₂e per tonne of cartons.
Calculation steps
- Normalise mass: from wet weighed mass, deduct contaminants and moisture to obtain tonnes of dry cartons; determine each brand's share of cartons through a brand audit.
- Define the baseline scenario for each locality: shares going to landfill, incineration and open burning, and the share already recycled through informal scrap collectors (this share is not credited to the programme).
- Calculate emission factors for each disposal route following the IPCC: landfill methane and fossil CO₂ from burning, net of electricity recovered by waste-to-energy plants.
- Calculate programme emissions: collection fuel, sorting electricity, long-haul transport to the plant, plant electricity and fuel, and fibre losses sent to landfill.
- Deduct material substitution benefits only where there is evidence that buyers actually use the fibre and PolyAl in place of other materials.
- Run low, central and high scenarios and publish a conservative figure together with the range.
Illustrative results
With default parameters, avoided emissions range from 0.6 to 3.3 tonnes of CO₂e per tonne of dry cartons, with a central value of 2.1, where cartons are mostly landfilled or openly burned. Applied to the four collection sites with the recycling plant in Ho Chi Minh City, the central values are 2.1 (Da Nang), 2.0 (Ho Chi Minh City), 0.8 (Quang Ninh) and 0.3 tonnes of CO₂e per tonne (Hanoi). Hanoi is lower because most of its waste already goes to waste-to-energy plants and because the cartons must travel about 1,720 km.
Taken together for the illustrative collection mix of the four localities, roughly every 1,000 tonnes of dry cartons recycled can avoid about 1,300 tonnes of CO₂e (range 500 to 2,200 tonnes), or about 1.3 kg of CO₂e per kg of cartons.
Notes on use
- The figures above are illustrative estimates based on sample data. Official programme factors require a survey of the baseline scenario, plant operating data and independent verification.
- Avoided emissions (Ledger B) are not a reduction in a company's greenhouse gas inventory, and do not reduce the mandatory facility-level inventory under Decree 06/2022/ND-CP (amended by Decree 119/2025/ND-CP).
- The same tonne of cartons should be claimed as avoided emissions by only one party, to prevent double counting between brands, packaging manufacturers, coordinators and recyclers.
Key references: IPCC (2006, 2019) Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories, Volume 5; GHG Protocol (2011, 2013) Scope 3 Standard and Technical Guidance; ISO 14064-1:2018, ISO 14064-2:2019; WBCSD (2023) Guidance on Avoided Emissions; Robertson (2021) Recycling 6(1):20; Turner et al. (2015) Resources, Conservation and Recycling 105; Zhang et al. (2026) Environmental Impact Assessment Review 116; Roland Berger (2022) report for ACE. The full reference list is in the downloadable document.
Read next

What Does Responsibly Sourced Recycled Plastic Really Cost? Key Takeaways from The Circulate Initiative's New Report

Hanoi's Waste Separation and Plastic Reduction Rules to 2031: What Partners Need to Know

Breaking the Circular Procurement Bottleneck: Can Advance Market Commitments (AMC) Solve the Recycled Plastic Shortage?
Are you a funder, organisation or business looking to create change with us? Get in touch.
